Tiffany & Co. is one of the most recognized luxury jewelry brands globally. If you have Tiffany jewelry to sell in NYC, understanding what affects its value helps you get the best offer.
What Tiffany Items Hold Value
Tiffany silver jewelry, 18K gold pieces, platinum engagement rings, and signed designer pieces (by Paloma Picasso, Elsa Peretti, etc.) all hold value. The iconic Tiffany setting engagement rings and Return to Tiffany collections are particularly popular on the secondary market.
Value Factors
The condition, original packaging (the famous blue box and pouch), receipt, and current demand all influence value. Having the original purchase receipt and packaging can add 10-20% to the offer.
Selling Tiffany in NYC
Choose a buyer who understands brand value. At Arthurs Gold Market, we recognize the premium that Tiffany & Co. commands and offer accordingly. Call (929) 693-0335 for a free evaluation.
Last updated: May 1, 2026
